Franchise Films: Hollywood’s Double-Edged Sword

Franchises have always been both a blessing and a curse for Hollywood. When successful, they can keep audiences engaged for years, even decades, with iconic series like James Bond, Batman, Star Wars, Mission: Impossible, and Superman. But eventually, audience fatigue sets in, and complaints about the lack of originality surface.

However, summer 2024 was a rare exception. For once, “franchise” wasn’t a dirty word. Big-name brands helped boost domestic box office earnings to over $5.4 billion by early September, still down 13% compared to the previous year, but much better than anticipated.

The turnaround began after a rough May, where The Fall Guy, a potential new franchise, flopped. Yet, Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga stormed the global box office with $172 million, building on the success of 2015’s Mad Max: Fury Road ($380 million). Another May highlight was Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes, one of the properties Disney acquired with its 2019 purchase of Fox assets. This film grossed nearly $400 million worldwide, ensuring director Wes Ball’s vision for a new trilogy would move forward. August’s Alien: Romulus also thrived, earning over $300 million globally—the franchise’s second-best showing behind 2012’s Prometheus.

The real box office rebound kicked off in June with Sony’s Boys: Ride or Die, which far exceeded expectations. In mid-June, Inside Out 2 set a new record for Pixar, becoming the highest-grossing animated film of all time, raking in $1.675 billion worldwide and ranking as the eighth-biggest film of all time. Meanwhile, Paramount expanded its A Quiet Place franchise with Day One ($261 million), and Universal, alongside Warner Bros., revived Twisters to the tune of $366 million.

Box office analyst Paul Dergarabedian noted that nearly every studio outperformed expectations this summer across a range of genres. Disney dominated with Inside Out 2, Deadpool & Wolverine, and Alien: Romulus. Universal saw success with Despicable Me 4 and Twisters, while Paramount rebounded from a shaky start with IF to see the film earn over $100 million. Sony capped off the summer with hits like Bad Boys: Ride or Die and the late-summer success It Ends with Us.

Deadpool & Wolverine was especially significant for Marvel Studios, grossing over $1.287 billion, making it the second-biggest film of the year and the top earner for the franchise. Disney, which had faced stiff competition from Universal the previous year, reclaimed its dominance with $1.5 billion in domestic summer ticket sales, accounting for 42% of the market. Titles like Apes and Alien were particularly rewarding for Disney, as they came from Fox’s library—making their revival a more complex but ultimately successful endeavor.

Warner Bros. also saw success with a rare September blockbuster, Tim Burton’s Beetlejuice Beetlejuice, which earned $147 million globally after its early September release. The next big test for Warner Bros. will be Joker: Folie à Deux, the highly anticipated musical sequel set to release on October 4, with predictions pointing to a $70 million opening. It faces high expectations after Todd Phillips’ 2019 Joker brought in $1.07 billion worldwide.

Franchise Pulse Check: What’s Hot, What’s Not

  1. Star Trek
    After 2016’s Star Trek Beyond underwhelmed with $343.5 million globally, Paramount has developed several new ideas but none have materialized. A more focused, character-driven approach like 1982’s Wrath of Khan could revitalize the series.
  2. Terminator
    Despite James Cameron and Linda Hamilton’s return, 2019’s Dark Fate flopped. However, Netflix’s new anime Terminator Zero suggests the franchise could succeed with a fresh approach.
  3. Reign of Fire
    The 2002 film starring Christian Bale and Matthew McConaughey was a box-office failure but developed a cult following. A reboot could merge elements of The Last of Us and Game of Thrones for a post-apocalyptic dragon epic.
  4. Pirates of the Caribbean
    The Pirates franchise has been sinking since 2017’s Dead Men Tell No Tales. A complete overhaul could tap into audiences’ enduring love for high-seas adventures.
  5. Conan the Barbarian
    Arnold Schwarzenegger has long advocated for a “grizzled Conan” film. Could this be the franchise’s version of Logan?
  6. Spawn
    The concept of redemption and battling through hell remains timeless. The hard-R version of Spawn has been in development at Blumhouse since 2017—what’s the holdup?
  7. Lethal Weapon
    Mel Gibson and Danny Glover are indeed getting too old for this. Rather than a revival, it might be time for a new cop-action franchise altogether.
  8. Halloween
    David Gordon Green successfully rebooted Michael Myers, but after almost 50 years, is it time to finally move on from the unstoppable masked killer trope?
  9. The Matrix
    Despite its influence, the Matrix series has seen diminishing returns, including the 2021 legacy sequel Resurrections. Maybe it’s time to let this one rest.
  10. The Crow
    Attempts to revive The Crow have been ongoing for years, from sequels to direct-to-video releases. It might be time to let this franchise finally take its final bow.

Latest Reviews